Skip to main content

Better Late Than Never Review: Battlefield 1




Oh Battlefield what happened?  You used to be great. With a new entry into the franchise out its high time we looked at the previous title. 

Battlefield 1 tackles the far less morally clear of the two world wars. There's not a lot of games about the Great War and for good reason. In addition to having less evil enemies the war was far less glorious. Many people died of disease in trenches, choked to death on the air around them in gas attacks, and lived broken lives in a world that didn't understand what a conflict like this had done to their psyche. The technology of war then was at once simpler and more terrifying. Most had access to only bolt action weapons while the latest technologies cut people down in droves. 

Battlefield, a series which has never had problems putting you on both sides of a conflict and equip the player with period weapons, opts here to give you a machine gun and point you at Prussians all day.  In fact, the game makes a point of pushing me towards better weapons at every opportunity. Like it thinks I'll loose interest if my gun isn't constantly firing.  

The single player experience is a number of war stories. Stories is right as the longest of these is only 4 levels. Not nearly enough time to become invested. The achievement says I'd finished the campaign but I'd be hard pressed to call this a campaign. 

For example the Australian segment covers the battle of Gallipoli. The game stresses it's a battle with "the largest navel fleet hereinto assembled".  It couldn't be bothered showing this or making the failed invasion feels as such.  Medal of Honor Frontline had a better beach landing for god sakes. 

Each war story also finds a reason to make you sneak around. No really, like with poorly implemented stealth mechanics. Now maybe I misread the title but this is Battlefield 1. From the Battlefield franchise. Why aren't we on more battlefields?  Surely there were plenty of them in the First World War.  Aside from one maybe two of the war stories they never make sense to force into the game. These stealth segments are made worse since there is really only one path to take. Never mind the diverse options and routes presented, the game demands one way and one way only. 

The writing is just plain bad. A combination of cliches and words someone heard in a war movie repeated without regard for the situation is present throughout all the war stories. Most character lack the depth present in even straightforward Battlefield titles, and none come near those in the Bad Company games. 

Sloppiness rounds out the experience. The game was happy to remind me to use my binoculars to scout ahead but the button on my controller for them refused to bring them up. Enemies that I hit would clip around me suddenly to get an elaborate bayonet stab on my AI allies. 

The multiplayer seems hardly worth mentioning. For one when I tried this time the game stubbornly refused to connect to EA online. I did play a little after release though  but there's not much to say. It's still fun. That's good I guess. I had trouble getting into it though because I had trouble getting into the mode.  


The good:
-The game looks visually stunning. 
-multiplayer is still fun. 

The bad:
-too much sneaking around. 
-less of a Battlefield game than a Call of Duty clone. 

As I played more the problem became clear. Battlefield 1 didn't want to tell a new story about the First World War or even be a battlefield game. It wanted to be Call of Duty. Specifically it wanted to BEAT Call of Duty. With CoD WWII being released the same year Battlefield maybe thought it needed to compete. Oh battlefield, we loved you just the way you were. 


It all a bit of a mess. Where's the battlefield that put 64 people on an open map and let us have at it?  Where's the battlefield that took the time and effort develop good characters?  I know that this Battlefield exists, I've played these games.  They were good games. Battlefield 1 is not. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The End

Today we end things on Breweriesandgames! in much the same way that we began, with a post whose first draft started in the notes app of my phone.  Our last post a year and a half after we began. Before I get into the meat of  things here’s your to-long, didn’t-read. We’re closing up.  This may not come as a surprise to longtime readers as it’s no secret that posts have been few and far between lately. To say nothing of having missed several important dates. Consistency is an important part of content creation and we haven’t been meeting the goals we set for ourselves. These also aren’t the only goals that aren’t being met.  I have a number of responsibilities, like anyone, and those have only grown in the past year and a half.  While I’ve never considered my obligations here any less important than other writing obligations, they do need to take a back seat to some of practical obligations in my life. In dividing my time, all parts have suffered. It’s n...

Brewery Review: The Rock Bottom Restaurant & Brewery Portland

Portland is known for a great many things. From bikes to bridges, music to markets, donuts to dogs.  Here though, it's Portlands brews that get us excited. This week we got to look another great one.  Flagship: Puddle Hopper IPA Dogs: service animals only Kids: yes Do they brew there: yes Food: Full menu Has guest taps: yes Events: yes Outside seating: no Wifi: yes Located in downtown near a shopping mall and one of the East serving bridges. This brewery is the Portland branch of the Rock Bottom Restaurant and Brewery chain but you wouldn't guess it when you go in.  Going in your greeted by lots of metal and glass. It's one of the common styles of both new breweries and restaurants alike for sure, but that doesn't mean it's not effective. Natural light gets in and the place feels inviting. The typical bar is joined by several other types of seating.  Booths, circular high tops, long tables. All the popular forms of seating have ...

Hey out there!

Greetings Internet!  My name is James Verzuh and I created this blog to talk about two of my passions:  breweries and video games. The goal of this blog is to have regular content about these two topics.  We're going to shoot for once a week. So here's the deal, every Thursday I'm going to give you my take on a brewery I've been to. I live in Seattle but I travel a lot so expect places from all over the Northwest.  Then, every Monday I'll have what I call a Better Late Than Never review of a game where I'll give you my take on a video game that's been out for at least a year. Divorced of the hype and probably sitting in a bargain bin near you, we'll see how these games hold up. If this all sounds good to you then grab a pint, a controller, and stick around for Breweries and Games!